My heavens! What’s this? … Really, what’s this you’re reading? A negative review about a site! I’ve only done this once before and have since re-reviewed the site I reviewed poorly and gave it a much better standing based on their improvements, let’s see how I do here.
Zeadoo. Okay, first off, if I made watercraft? I’d kick these guys all the way to the US patent office for trademark infringement, but they’re not, and I’m not, so I believe they’re safe from any seizures, lawsuits, etc. But they’re not safe from Sociosophy.
I’m very forgiving with new sites, betas, hell… I even find the good in sites that barely have any. But something about Zeadoo pissed me off, and it’s simple. Too much bull to get to your shit.
I watched the Zeadoo video, created an account – let’s face it, it looked pretty straight forward in their demo. It’s a whole other story once you’re in there though. If you’ve ever used StumbleUpon, Delicious, Magnol.ia… hell even your own Bookmarking feature in your browser, you’ll loath Zeadoo. The cumbersome and tedious process of data entry for all your bookmarks, even with a bookmarking Firefox plug in, make this site remind me of hand input data record days back at my first tech job.
Perhaps a remedy will be to allow imports of favorites from other sites, but even still, adding new ones is simply too many steps. Bad UI planning, damn it. Interacting with them via the “Dashboard” is also simply too much… My attention span on the Nowternet is about || < that short, and like I said, I’m a nice guy on the net looking for the good in sites.
Zeadoo, your logo is pretty, the concept is nice – it’s not new – but you guys have GOT to look at your market before you design something more complicated than any other solution like yours out there. Especially this late in the game.